Powered By Blogger

ShareThis

Showing posts with label LABOR LAW. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LABOR LAW. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 01, 2013

LABOR DAY


"Social justice is not a mere catchphrase to be mouthed with sham fervor in Labor Day celebrations for the delectation and seduction of the working class. It is a mandate we should pursue with energy and sincerity if we are to truly insure the dignity and well-being of the laborer."

- Dissenting Opinion of Justice Cruz, Republic v.Peralta, G.R.No. L-56568, May 20, 1987.



Monday, April 29, 2013

MAY THE DOLE SECRETARY DETERMINE THE EXISTENCE OF EMPLOYER-EMPLOYEE RELATIONSHIP?


IN THE EXERCISE OF ITS VISITORIAL AND ENFORCEMENT POWERS, MAY THE DOLE DETERMINE THE EXISTENCE OF AN EMPLOYER-EMPLOYEE RELATIONSHIP TO THE EXLCUSION OF THE NLRC?

Yes.  Under Art. 128(b) of the Labor Code, as amended by RA 7730, the DOLE is fully empowered to make a determination as to the existence of an employer-employee relationship in the exercise of its expanded visitorial and enforcement power. And this determination by the DOLE of the existence of an employer-employee relationship is not merely provisional or subordinate to the NLRC’s determination. When the DOLE finds the existence of such relationship, the same is not even subject to NLRC’s review. Instead, DOLE’s determination is directly subject to judicial review. However, it bears emphasis that if the DOLE finds that no such relationship exists or the same has been terminated, jurisdiction is with the NLRC. 

In its Resolution PEOPLE’S BROADCASTING SERVICE (BOMBO RADYOPHILS., INC.) vs. SECRETARY OF DOLE, G.R. No. 179652, March 6, 2012, the Supreme Court, en banc, modified its earlier decision as follows:

The prior decision of this Court in the present case accepts such answer, but places a limitation upon the power of the DOLE, that is, the determination of the existence of an employer-employee relationship cannot be co-extensive with the visitorial and enforcement power of the DOLE.  But even in conceding the power of the DOLE to determine the existence of an employer-employee relationship, the Court held that the determination of the existence of an employer-employee relationship is still primarily within the power of the NLRC, that any finding by the DOLE is merely preliminary.

This conclusion must be revisited.

No limitation in the law was placed upon the power of the DOLE to determine the existence of an employer-employee relationship.  No procedure was laid down where the DOLE would only make a preliminary finding, that the power was primarily held by the NLRC.  The law did not say that the DOLE would first seek the NLRC’s determination of the existence of an employer-employee relationship, or that should the existence of the employer-employee relationship be disputed, the DOLE would refer the matter to the NLRC.  The DOLE must have the power to determine whether or not an employer-employee relationship exists, and from there to decide whether or not to issue compliance orders in accordance with Art. 128(b) of the Labor Code, as amended by RA 7730.xxx

xxx The determination of the existence of an employer-employee relationship by the DOLE must be respected.  The expanded visitorial and enforcement power of the DOLE granted by RA 7730 would be rendered nugatory if the alleged employer could, by the simple expedient of disputing the employer-employee relationship, force the referral of the matter to the NLRC.  The Court issued the declaration that at least a prima facie showing of the absence of an employer-employee relationship be made to oust the DOLE of jurisdiction.  But it is precisely the DOLE that will be faced with that evidence, and it is the DOLE that will weigh it, to see if the same does successfully refute the existence of an employer-employee relationship.
If the DOLE makes a finding that there is an existing employer-employee relationship, it takes cognizance of the matter, to the exclusion of the NLRC.  The DOLE would have no jurisdiction only if the employer-employee relationship has already been terminated, or it appears, upon review, that no employer-employee relationship existed in the first place. 
The Court, in limiting the power of the DOLE, gave the rationale that such limitation would eliminate the prospect of competing conclusions between the DOLE and the NLRC.  The prospect of competing conclusions could just as well have been eliminated by according respect to the DOLE findings, to the exclusion of the NLRC, and this We believe is the more prudent course of action to take.
This is not to say that the determination by the DOLE is beyond question or review.  Suffice it to say, there are judicial remedies such as a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 that may be availed of, should a party wish to dispute the findings of the DOLE.
It must also be remembered that the power of the DOLE to determine the existence of an employer-employee relationship need not necessarily result in an affirmative finding.  The DOLE may well make the determination that no employer-employee relationship exists, thus divesting itself of jurisdiction over the case.  It must not be precluded from being able to reach its own conclusions, not by the parties, and certainly not by this Court.

As summarized by the Supreme Court, the following are the rules regarding the jurisdiction of the DOLE, NLRC and Labor Arbiter:

To recapitulate, if a complaint is brought before the DOLE to give effect to the labor standards provisions of the Labor Code or other labor legislation, and there is a finding by the DOLE that there is an existing employer-employee relationship, the DOLE exercises jurisdiction to the exclusion of the NLRC.  If the DOLE finds that there is no employer-employee relationship, the jurisdiction is properly with the NLRC.  If a complaint is filed with the DOLE, and it is accompanied by a claim for reinstatement, the jurisdiction is properly with the Labor Arbiter, under Art. 217(3) of the Labor Code, which provides that the Labor Arbiter has original and exclusive jurisdiction over those cases involving wages, rates of pay, hours of work, and other terms and conditions of employment, if accompanied by a claim for reinstatement. If a complaint is filed with the NLRC, and there is still an existing employer-employee relationship, the jurisdiction is properly with the DOLE.  The findings of the DOLE, however, may still be questioned through a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court.








Monday, April 15, 2013

IS THE EMPLOYEE REQUIRED TO DISPROVE PAYMENT OF BENEFITS DUE HIM?


It is not for an employee to prove non-payment of benefits to which he is entitled by law. Rather, it is on the employer that the burden of proving payment of these claims rests.

SCII (employer) presented payroll listings and transmittal letters to the bank to show that Canoy and Pigcaulan (employees) received their salaries as well as benefits which it claimed are already integrated in the employees’ monthly salaries. However, the documents presented do not prove SCII’s allegation.  SCII failed to show any other concrete proof by means of records, pertinent files or similar documents reflecting that the specific claims have been paid.  With respect to 13th month pay, SCII presented proof that this benefit was paid but only for the years 1998 and 1999.  To repeat, the burden of proving payment of these monetary claims rests on SCII, being the employer.  It is a rule that one who pleads payment has the burden of proving it.  “Even when the plaintiff alleges non-payment, still the general rule is that the burden rests on the defendant to prove payment, rather than on the plaintiff to prove non-payment.” Since SCII failed to provide convincing proof that it has already settled the claims, Pigcaulan should be paid his holiday pay, service incentive leave benefits and proportionate 13th month pay for the year 2000. (ABDULJUAHID R. PIGCAULAN  vs. SECURITY  and CREDIT INVESTIGATION,INC., G.R. No. 173648, January 16, 2012)



Wednesday, April 03, 2013

TERMINATION OF PROBATIONARY EMPLOYEE: REFUSAL TO ATTEND VALUES FORMATION SEMINAR


Interestingly, the Supreme Court, in one recent case, found that refusal to attend the company’s (employer) “Values Formation Seminar” was a sufficient basis to terminate a probationary employee.

The pertinent discussions as embodied in the Decision are quoted as follows:

Dalangin overlooks the fact, wittingly or unwittingly, that he offered glimpses of his own behavior and actuations during his four-week stay with the company; he betrayed his negative attitude and regard for the company, his co-employees and his work.
Dalangin admitted in compulsory arbitration that the proximate cause for his dismissal was his refusal to attend the company’s “Values Formation Seminar” scheduled for October 27, 2001, a Saturday. He refused to attend the seminar after he learned that it had no relation to his duties, as he claimed, and that he had to leave at 2:00 p.m. because he wanted to be with his family in the province.  When Abad insisted that he attend the seminar to encourage his co-employees to attend, he stood pat on not attending, arguing that marked differences exist between their positions and duties, and insinuating that he did not want to join the other employees. He also questioned the scheduled 2:00 p.m. seminars on Saturdays as they were not supposed to be doing a company activity beyond 2:00 p.m. He considers 2:00 p.m. as the close of working hours on Saturdays; thus, holding them beyond 2:00 p.m. would be in violation of the law.
The “Values Formation Seminar” incident is an eye-opener on the kind of person and employee Dalangin was. His refusal to attend the seminar brings into focus and validates what was wrong with him, as Abad narrated in her affidavit[36] and as reflected in the termination of employment memorandum.[37] It highlights his lack of interest in familiarizing himself  with the company’s objectives and policies. Significantly, the seminar involved acquainting and updating the employees with the company’s policies and objectives.  Had he attended the seminar, Dalangin could have broadened his awareness of the company’s policies, in addition to Abad’s briefing him about the company’s policies on punctuality and attendance, and the procedures to be followed in handling the clients’ applications. No wonder the company charged him with obstinacy.
The incident also reveals Dalangin’s lack of interest in establishing good working relationship with his co-employees, especially the rank and file; he did not want to join them because of his view that the seminar was not relevant to his position and duties. It also betrays an arrogant and condescending attitude on his part towards his co-employees, and a lack of support for the company objective that company managers be examples to the rank and file employees. xxx
xxx We, therefore, disagree with the CA that the company could not have fully determined Dalangin’s performance barely one month into his employment. As we said in International Catholic Migration Commission, the probationary term or period denotes its purpose but not its length.  To our mind, four weeks was enough for the company to assess Dalangin’s fitness for the job and he was found wanting. In separating Dalangin from the service before the situation got worse, we find the company not liable for illegal dismissal.xxx




Sunday, March 17, 2013

"BATAS KASAMBAHAY" OR "DOMESTIC WORKERS ACT"



Recently, Republic Act No. 10361 or otherwise known as the “Domestic Workers Act” or “Batas Kasambahay” was passed. This law defines the basic terms and conditions that must be afforded to the “house-helpers” or the “kasambahay.”

Among the salient provisions are: (1) the right of the “kasambahay” to have the opportunity to finish basic education even while working as such. For this purpose, the law requires the employer to adjust the work schedule of the domestic worker to allow such access to education or training without hampering the services required by the employer; (2) the execution of a written contract of employment in a language known to the domestic worker wherein all the basic terms and conditions of employment are to be embodied; (3) the prohibition against placing the domestic worker under debt bondage; (4) the required provision for daily and weekly rest periods; (5) non-assignment for non-household work unless the domestic worker is paid with the applicable minimum wage for the extra work assigned to him/her; (5) payment of minimum wage for domestic workers as may be determined from time to time [Initial minimum wages: P 2,500/month in NCR; P 2,000/month in chartered cities and first class municipalities; P 1,500 in all other municipalities]; (6) entitlement of domestic workers to 13th month pay, leave benefits, mandatory SSS, Pag-ibig, Philhealth coverage; (7) prohibition against unjustified dismissal from employment; and (8) civil and criminal liabilities of the employer for violations of the law.

The new law is a welcome development for the lowly and marginalized household workers. There are also provisions that actually protect the legitimate interests of the employers. So, employers should not take the law against them. (Read the full text of Republic Act No, 10361 here!)



DISQUS