Powered By Blogger

ShareThis

Showing posts with label PROPERTY. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PROPERTY. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

IN TESTAMENTARY SUCCESSION, IS THE TESTATOR PRESUMED TO BE OF SOUND MIND?


It is incumbent upon those who oppose the probate of a will to clearly establish that the decedent was not of sound and disposing mind at the time of the execution of said will. Otherwise, the state is duty-bound to give full effect to the wishes of the testator to distribute his estate in the manner provided in his will so long as it is legally tenable.

Pursuant to Article 800 of the New Civil Code, every person is presumed to be of sound mind, in the absence of proof to the contrary. The burden of proof that the testator was not of sound mind at the time of making his dispositions is on the person who opposes the probate of the will; but if the testator, one month, or less, before making his will was publicly known to be insane, the person who maintains the validity of the will must prove that the testator made it during a lucid interval. 

Here, there was no showing that Paciencia was publicly known to be insane one month or less before the making of the Will.  Clearly, thus, the burden to prove that Paciencia was of unsound mind lies upon the shoulders of petitioners.  However and as earlier mentioned, no substantial evidence was presented by them to prove the same, thereby warranting the CA’s finding that petitioners failed to discharge such burden.

Courts are tasked to determine nothing more than the extrinsic validity of a Will in probate proceedings.

xxx Here, a careful examination of the face of the Will shows faithful compliance with the formalities laid down by law.  The signatures of the testatrix, Paciencia, her instrumental witnesses and the notary public, are all present and evident on the Will.  Further, the attestation clause explicitly states the critical requirement that the testatrix and her instrumental witnesses signed the Will in the presence of one another and that the witnesses attested and subscribed to the Will in the presence of the testator and of one another.  In fact, even the petitioners acceded that the signature of Paciencia in the Will may be authentic although they question her state of mind when she signed the same as well as the voluntary nature of said act. xxx (BALTAZAR vs. LAXA, G.R. No.174489, April 11, 2012)

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

CAN A FOREIGNER OWN LAND IN THE PHILIPPINES?


          In particular, can a foreign national apply for registration of title over a parcel of land which he acquired by purchase while still a Filipino citizen?

Monday, March 11, 2013

PRIMARY JURISDICTION OVER PUBLIC LAND OWNERSHIP BELONGS TO DENR, NOT TO REGULAR COURTS.


In BAGUNU VS. SPS. AGGABAO, G.R. NO. 186487, AUGUST 15, 2011, the question as to who between the DENR and the regular courts has primary jurisdiction over matters of land ownership was clarified. Primary jurisdiction over matters of public land ownership belongs to the Director of Lands, subject to review by the DENR Secretary. On the other hand, jurisdiction over matters of private land ownership is exclusively vested with the regular courts.

            The pertinent portions of the pronouncement are quoted as follows:

       The petitioner insists that under the law actions incapable of pecuniary estimation, to which a suit for reformation of contracts belong, and those involving ownership of real property fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Court. Since these actions are already pending before the RTC, the DENR Secretary overstepped his authority in excluding Lot 322 from the petitioner’s free patent application and ordering the respondents to apply for a free patent over the same lot.

     In an action for reformation of contract, the court determines whether the parties’ written agreement reflects their true intention. In the present case, this intention refers to the identity of the land covered by the second and third sale. On the other hand, in a reivindicatory action, the court resolves the issue of ownership of real property and the plaintiff’s entitlement to recover its full possession. In this action, the plaintiff is required to prove not only his ownership, but also the identity of the real property he seeks to recover.

    While these actions ordinarily fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the RTC, the court’s jurisdiction to resolve controversies involving ownership of real property extends only to private lands. In the present case, neither party has asserted private ownership over Lot 322. The respondents acknowledged the public character of Lot 322 by mainly relying on the administrative findings of the DENR in their complaint-in-intervention, instead of asserting their own private ownership of the property. For his part, the petitioner’s act of applying for a free patent with the Bureau of Lands is an acknowledgment that the land covered by his application is a public land whose management and disposition belong to the DENR Secretary, with the assistance of the Bureau of Lands.

Xxxx
            The resolution of conflicting claims of ownership over real property is within the regular courts’ area of competence and, concededly, this issue is judicial in character. However, regular courts would have no power to conclusively resolve this issue of ownership given the public character of the land, since under C.A. No. 141, in relation to Executive Order No. 192, the disposition and management of public lands fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Director of Lands, subject to review by the DENR Secretary.
Xxxx


            With this clarification, it should now be clear that jurisdiction on questions of land ownership is determined by the nature of the land involved. If the land is still a public land, then the DENR has primary jurisdiction. If the subject land is already a private land, the authority to adjudicate matters of ownership belongs with the regular courts. 

DISQUS